Skip to content
IGCSE·Tuition
English as a Second Language · Lesson

Use modal verbs to distinguish certainty and possibility

You want to sound sure about one idea and careful about another, but the verbs on the page sound equally confident.

On this page
  1. How do the modals rank for certainty?
  2. Worked example
  3. The mistake to watch for
  4. Check yourself
  5. Where this leads next

Modal verbs show how certain or possible something is. Will, must, should, may, might and could all sit in front of another verb and change how strongly the writer commits to the statement. In reports, reviews and speaking discussions, your choice of modal is part of your opinion.

This is the last lesson in grammar for clear meaning and it builds on the cause and contrast links from the previous lesson.

How do the modals rank for certainty?

Think of a scale from almost sure to only possible.

StrengthModalMeaningExample
Very highwill, mustCertain, or a strong conclusionThe shop will open at nine. The door is locked, so it must be closed.
Expectedshould, ought toReasonable expectationThe parcel should arrive tomorrow.
Possiblemay, might, couldReal chance, not sureIt may rain later. She could be in the library.
Very lowmight not, could notDoubtful or impossibleHe might not finish in time. That could not be true.

Two points keep the choices clear. First, must for a conclusion comes from evidence you can see. Second, can describes ability or general possibility, not a guess about a particular situation.

All modals use the base form of the next verb: must be, might go, should arrive.

Worked example

Rewrite the sentence so the certainty matches the evidence: The museum is full of people, so it is open. The sign says school groups arrive at ten, so the noise is loud.

Step 1, ask how strong the evidence is. A full museum is strong evidence that it is open. The noise is an assumption from a sign, so it is less certain.

Step 2, choose for the first claim. Strong evidence suggests must: The museum is full of people, so it must be open.

Step 3, choose for the second claim. The sign gives a reason to expect noise, not proof: so it might be loud or so it should be loud.

Step 4, choose the final wording. The museum is full of people, so it must be open. The sign says school groups arrive at ten, so it might be loud by then.

Step 5, check the verb forms. After must and might there is be, the base form.

The mistake to watch for

A frequent slip is stating a guess as a fact, or hedging a fact that is certain.

Mistaken sentence: The results are not on the website yet, so they will be late.

The writer cannot know this, yet the modal presents it as certain.

Correction: The results are not on the website yet, so they may be late. The evidence supports a possibility, not a certainty. Reverse the error too: Water might boil at 100 °C at sea level weakens a known fact. Write Water boils at 100 °C at sea level.

A second slip is adding to or an -s ending: She might to go, He can goes.

Check yourself

Try these, then open each answer.

1. Choose the most suitable modal: Her coat is on the chair and her bag is here, so she ___ be nearby. (must / might / will)

Show answer

must. Her coat and bag are strong evidence, so the conclusion is almost certain.

2. Correct: It could to rain tomorrow.

Show answer

It could rain tomorrow. No to after a modal verb.

3. A friend has not replied to your message for one hour. Write a careful sentence about why.

Show answer

She might be busy. or She may not have seen it yet. An hour of silence is weak evidence, so possibility modals fit better than must.

Where this leads next

With all five lessons done, test yourself with the mixed grammar practice set. Then continue to sentence building and paraphrase, where accurate grammar helps you restate ideas in your own words.

If you often hear yourself sounding either too certain or too vague, a teacher can rehearse the difference with you in online one-to-one English as a Second Language tuition.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between 'must' and 'should' for a conclusion?

Must shows you are almost certain, based on evidence, as in 'The lights are off, so they must be asleep'. Should shows a reasonable expectation with less certainty, as in 'The train should arrive at six'. If you are not sure, choose may, might or could.

Can I use 'may' and 'might' in the same way?

In most writing they are close in meaning and both show real possibility. Might can feel slightly less likely. Both are followed by the base form: 'She may win', not 'She may wins'. Keep the same choice across a paragraph for a steady tone.

Do I add 'to' after a modal verb?

No. Modals such as can, could, must, may, might, will and should are followed by the plain verb without to: 'You must check', not 'You must to check'. The exceptions are expressions like have to and ought to, which are not true modals.

Updated:

Your next step

If you are unsure how strongly to state a point in a report or discussion, a one-to-one teacher can work through your own claims and show how each modal changes what you are promising.

Paid one-hour trial at your assigned teacher’s confirmed rate, starting from RM80.

Tuition is arranged with a parent or guardian. Send them this page on WhatsApp and they can enquire for you.

Parents: enquire here

  • 9,000+ students helped through our service
  • 9+ years helping IGCSE students